Nashville’s Charters Sidestep Chatter and Run Up the Score

My grandmother would always say, “I can show you better than I can tell you.” It was a mantra she lived by, which meant, in practical terms, that if someone crossed her, she might not say much, but you could bet your bottom dollar swift and decisive action was sure to follow.

I think the charter school leaders and parents might be taking a page from my grandmother’s playbook.

For a while, I’ve watched in frustration as, Nashville school board members and privileged “pro-public school” parents have executed all-out attacks on public charter schools in our city. I’ve seen effective and passionate charter leaders of color ousted, and good schools get their petitions to recharter denied.

All along I was even more frustrated by the fact the those under siege almost never raised a voice in protest. They wouldn’t fight back!

It wasn’t until I got to know Mia Howard that I started to realize what might be going on. It was Howard, the founder and executive director at Intrepid charter schools, that pulled the little chain on the light bulb in my brain and made me realize that charter leaders and supporters might be taking a page out of my grandmother’s playbook.

Last July, the Nashville Scene published a story celebrating the silence of charter backers after a series of “losses.” Angry, I tweeted “my guess is that the charter backers are quiet because they are SCARED AS S%$! And the media only exacerbates their fears. Sponsors it.” Howard, wasting no time, replied, “Not scared. Some of us are just here to educate children at the highest level. Disrupting inequity by design takes focus. No distractions.”

In other words, “I can show you better than I can tell you.”

While I was angry-tweeting about fearful charter supporters, Mia Howard’s Intrepid Schools were in the throes of flipping the narrative for Hispanic and Black students which make up the majority of their enrollment. Script-flipping statistics like: “Intrepid scholars placed #5 in the district for ELA achievement in grades 6-8.” Further, Black students placed #4 in the district for ELA in the same grades.

Compare that to the district-wide average: only 17 percent of minority students are reading in grade level.

And then there’s Math: 100% of black and brown students scored On-Track or Mastered in Algebra I and ELL students were #1 in Math achievement for grades 6-8. Anyone would be hard-pressed to ignore these life-changing achievements, but, to my knowledge, they’ve received no recognition from the school board, media, Metro Council, or even the mayor.

Just silence.

For more of Intrepid’s inequity-disrupting statistics, click here.

And speaking of silence. Do you ever hear from Valor Collegiate? The growing charter management organization of schools that prides itself on its racially and socio-economically-balanced student population that sits atop a hill above a bustling corridor in South Nashville. It seems they work very hard to avoid the city’s volatility toward charters and, like Intrepid, focuses intently on doing what they do. And what is it that they do, you ask?

Well, while I was sitting around pondering the whereabouts of Valor reps during times of distress on the edu-battlefield, Valor Voyager and Valor Flagship were busy becoming #3 and #4, respectively, in the state in composite growth. Let’s put it this way, CEO Todd Dickson and CCO (chief culture officer) Daren Dickson are fighting the haters on their own terms and Valor scholars are the reigning champs. For instance, “Our economically disadvantaged scholars inverted the achievement gap, meaning that they outperformed non-economically disadvantaged scholars in Nashville and the State of Tennessee!” Can you say #FliptheScript?

Message received and they didn’t have to say a word.

Finally, there is a Teach for America-generated graphic that keeps making an appearance on Twitter by NashvilleEdReform. It shows every middle and high school in the district and its placement on the growth chart. I am no fan of school comparisons–it’s difficult for me to celebrate schools in the face of less successful ones. Maybe it’s the socialist in me.

But to ignore this picture is to join forces with those who refuse to acknowledge the success charters schools are having in this city. I simply cannot be on the wrong side of silence. I will celebrate those who subdue their naysayers without using words, but with student successes.

Note: the three top-ranked growth schools are mentioned in this post.

 

Back to School Nashville: Mia Howard and the Power of Problem Solving

Guest blogger Mia Howard, Founder and CEO of Intrepid College Prep schools.

When I was in first grade and attending NYC public schools in the early nineties, citywide assessments were commonplace. That spring, we took a math exam. I was too young to be nervous or to fully understand its importance – that came in later grades. But I vividly remember the last problem. Students were asked to find the area of a triangle. The shape consisted of unit squares so I counted the unit squares.

When I realized that some of the parts do not cover a complete square, I combined those to make whole squares and then counted them as well. Using that strategy, I derived the area of the triangle. I had no idea if I was right but I turned my exam in with minutes to spare. Not even 5 minutes later, my teacher called me to her desk. Incredulous, my teacher asked me how I solved the problem. Her tone told me that I got it right but it also told me she didn’t expect me to do so. Even at six years old, students can perceive when teachers have low expectations for them.

Tennessee and the Common Core now consider this type of problem par for the course in third grade. I mastered it two years earlier. Low and behold, I got one of the top scores in the city on that exam; my performance was commended with a ceremony, medal and royal blue letterman style jacket with ‘Math Champion’ emblazoned on the back. I still have it stored away in my closet somewhere.

Fast forward twenty-something years later. Six years ago, I had the opportunity to apply for the extremely competitive Building Excellent Schools Fellowship program.  As part of that process, which evaluates readiness to design, found and lead a high-performing school committed to closing the achievement gap, I was asked to analyze a sample school budget. There were terms I was unfamiliar with and the exercise required a variety of math skills that I had to figure out how to put together to evaluate the health of the school and make key decisions – all with no prior experience in school administration. I relied on critical-reasoning skills that I’ve been developing since elementary school, thanks to some great teachers, and demonstrated a solid understanding of charter school finance basics. Even better, I was granted the opportunity of a lifetime – a chance to build Intrepid College Prep, a successful middle and high school in Nashville.

What these two experiences demonstrate is that students and young people only realize their full potential when they are stretched academically and given the opportunity to engage in productive struggle while tackling problems that allow them to leverage what they do know to figure out something they do not know. Still, it took me a long time to apply that understanding to the way we teach mathematics at Intrepid College Prep.

We implemented the Tennessee standards, which borrow heavily from the Common Core, but until recently we focused too much on rote memorization and procedural skill and not enough on helping kids understand the concepts behind the problems, and how to apply their knowledge. In doing so, I confronted another iteration of the bias held by my first-grade teacher – lowering expectations for our students based on their academic challenges in math. It was evident when I walked into a classroom and saw students struggle to put their thinking on paper. It was evident when I listened to student discussions about math and noticed that their ideas were often incoherent. They struggled, in part, because we didn’t give them adequate time and support to engage in productive struggle.

However, one of the bright spots of our organization is knowing what we don’t know and asking for help. Earlier this year we reached out to The Achievement Network to help us diagnose the problem and design a plan of attack. After months of observation and planning, we are excited to shift our approach to teaching in three different ways starting this fall that we believe will increase math knowledge, understanding and performance.

What We’re Changing

  • Study the major work in every grade to understand the demands and aspects of rigor called for by the standards.  Use the language of the standards to implement specific and varied instructional practices based on each aspect of rigor – conceptual understanding, procedural skill and fluency, and application.

 

  • Pose high-quality questions and problems to engage students in meaningful work and discussion and deliberately check for understanding.

 

  • Shift teacher development from creating materials to internalizing content.

Our Key Investments

We invested in leadership and teacher coaching to support these priorities. We also decided to fully adopt the Eureka Math curriculum from UnboundEd, which teaches students and teachers how to excel in math using a variety of aligned instructional practices while increasing student ownership of each lesson. With support from professors at The Wharton School, we have also designed a financial literacy curriculum that has an interdisciplinary focus on using the humanities and conceptual understanding of math to create social entrepreneurs. We will give our students exposure to real world problem solving about issues that are meaningful to them. Students will use critical reasoning skills and their understanding of literacy, the social sciences, and mathematics to design solutions to pressing social issues.

Our Key People

Our teachers will bring these shifts to life but these instructional shifts also live and breathe across our organization. This summer we shared these instructional priorities with our network team and our campus leaders and together we examined what effective teacher and student practices must be evident to signal that the shifts are increasing student achievement qualitatively and quantitatively. We expect every leader, including members of our operations team, to be able to describe these shifts and gather evidence of success when they are in classrooms.

Most importantly, we restructured principal responsibilities to make sure that our principals are equipped with the resources and skills to support these shifts in classrooms every day. We’ve designed the principal role around their ability to spend 50% time in classrooms and we’ve added Operations Associates to each campus to provide more administrative support that will protect that dedicated instructional time. We each have a unique role to play in supporting instruction. As adults, the importance of teamwork to solve problems is clear. Our schools bear the responsibility of giving students similar experiences inside and outside the classroom.

Our Key Takeaways

For any teachers or leaders struggling to make the more rigorous math standards come alive in the classroom, know that you are not alone.  On those days when math is messy and you feel tempted to rein it in and go back to teacher-controlled classrooms, lean in even more. When parents complain that we’re teaching math the “wrong” way, persevere. Reach out to schools and leaders that are data-proven and observe their math classrooms. Study the teacher actions pre-, during and post-lesson to understand how teachers internalize math content and develop confidence in the various ways to solve problems while addressing student misconceptions. Rise to rigor. A world where our students are the future problem-solvers depends on it.

 

Founder and Leader Mia Howard, Mastermind Behind Success at Intrepid College Prep Schools

Screenshot 2017-06-15 at 9.49.23 AM

“We Build Relationship Systems.”

A school that bakes parent engagement into its strategy for student success is a school after my own heart.  Intrepid College Prep Schools, a Tennessee reward school scoring in the top 5% of schools in the state, is a superstar in an ever-growing, beautifully diverse southeast Nashville. Opportunity Academy, the organization’s flagship middle school with students in grades 5-8, sits in the busy, traffic-burdened Antioch ‘business district’ and housed in a nondescript building adjacent to a church.

I had an opportunity recently to delve into the world of a charter school founder who still leads the school while boasting improvement from its launch until today. Mia Howard is a straightforward, no-nonsense CEO with a quiet confidence that could rival Muhammad Ali. Very early in our conversation I got the impression that Ms. Howard never leaves well enough alone, that excellence is something for which to strive, not attain. So when the Brooklyn native says “This is our best year yet!” I believe her.

Recipe for Success

Ms. Howard knows exactly why her school is successful at preparing its students for

Screen Shot 2017-06-16 at 6.14.42 AM
Credit: Nashville Business Journal’s 40 Under 40

college. Relationships and data. Yes, the touchy-feely stuff and reliance on numbers (“numbers do not lie”) are what makes this school soar. Interestingly, relationship-building does not fall in the half-hearted, olive-branch category that it is typically assigned. Relationships with parents, teachers, and amongst school leadership is an integral part of the strategy of success for Intrepid’s students. So, even relationships are informed by data!

And when it comes to parents, Ms. Howard says, “parents are so important because they chose us.” The school has an open door policy and treats parents as peers and considers itself a school that belongs to parents and students. Little wonder why 88% of parents attend report card conferences – striking for a middle school.
 

Speaking of Data

Screen Shot 2017-06-07 at 12.49.07 PM
“Measuring results, not intentions” is in big bold letters on the school’s website.
The student population at the four-year-old school is 51.7% Hispanic, 24.2% Black, and 21.8% White, 35.6% English-learners and 89% economically disadvantaged. For Intrepid, this data is used to inform—not make excuses. And the CEO knows precisely what needs to happen to increase achievement and close gaps between diverse student groups.
Intrepid’s Dean of Culture analyzes data weekly, including whether or not teachers are calling parents every two weeks as required. It’s tough to separate relationship-building and use of data because they work hand-in-hand at Intrepid. Internal and external relationships are nurtured and continuously improved.   
 

“We agree to close our school if we do not deliver for kids”

 
The anti-charter school noise does not distract Mia Howard from the mission of educating Intrepid’s students because creating a proof point where 90% of Intrepid alumni complete four-year colleges is at stake. Of course, Howard is well aware of the negative narrative pushed out there, but knows it can be easily dispelled with numbers (remember, “numbers do not lie”). She also understands that taking her eye off the prize runs the risk of losing a high-quality option serving traditionally underserved students in a severely overcrowded part of the county. It’s not a risk she’s willing to take, because the babies. There’s a reason she has been recognized in the Nashville Business Journal’s 40 Under 40!

And They’re Off!

IMG_1742
Location for Independence High School opening Fall of 2017
In the fall of 2017, 97% of Intrepid’s current eighth-graders will matriculate to the new Independence High School opening in a recently purchased building near the middle school. In addition to satisfied students and families, Howard proudly clued me in on the high retention of her middle school students – above 90% in all grades – and teachers and leadership – 88%.
Considering what an indelible impact Intrepid College Prep Schools is making on the southeastern corner of Davidson County, I’m already looking forward to writing about Independence High’s first college signing day in 2021!